Premium CheesecakesBoulder Creek, California

Garrett's Famous Cheesecakes

Garrett's Famous Cheesecakes, back to the top
Call Garrett: 831-338-4173

“Cheesecakes Forever”

Garrett Wallace

Owner

831-338-4173

Boulder Creek, California

Plain Cheesecakes – Custom Cheesecakes

Every award winning cheesecake is 9 inches and made with premium ingredients. All cheesecakes are $70 and include free local delivery within the San Lorenzo Valley. Payment method is Cash ONLY.

Garrett’s No. 1 seller: Luscious Meyer Lemon

“People can’t put it down. They really love it.”

Garrett

Lemon curd on top, graham cracker crust. 9 inches, $70.

A drawing, not a photo: the springform comes off, lemon curd goes on, and a slice is served.

Garrett’s cheesecakes

Every cheesecake is baked in a 9-inch springform pan and costs $70. Add the topping of your choice for $15. Pumpkin and eggnog are for the holidays.

Luscious Meyer Lemon

Garrett’s No. 1 seller

On top
Lemon curd
Crust
Graham cracker
Price
$70

Plain Jane

On top
Plain, or add cherries or mandarin oranges
Crust
Your choice
Price
$70

Kahlúa & Chocolate Lovers’

Crust
Your choice
Price
$70

Rum & Raisin

Crust
Your choice
Price
$70

Mango

Crust
Your choice
Price
$70

Pumpkin

Crust
Your choice
Price
$70
Holiday

Eggnog

Crust
Your choice
Price
$70
Holiday

The pictures are drawings, not photos. For photos of Garrett’s real cheesecakes, see his fair entries.

Custom cheesecakes

Pick the crust and the topping, and tell Garrett when you call.

The crust

  • Graham cracker
  • Oreo cookie
  • Shortbread
  • Any cookie you like

A topping, $15

  • Cherries
  • Mandarin oranges
  • Something else? Ask Garrett

The size

A 9-inch springform pan, seen from above 9 in

Every cheesecake is a 9-inch springform.

Two vintage tractors, a green John Deere and a gray Ford, in the tractor parade at the Santa Cruz County Fair, with fairgoers, a barbecue stand and redwoods behind

11 years at the Santa Cruz County Fair

The tractor parade at the Santa Cruz County Fair, 2014 · Photo: fogcat5 / Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0, cropped

33 blue ribbons

Garrett has entered the Santa Cruz County Fair in Watsonville for 11 years. He has brought home 33 blue ribbons, 10 second-place ribbons and 4 third-place ribbons.

Blue for first place, red for second (10 of those), plus 4 third-place ribbons, from 11 years at the Santa Cruz County Fair

Some of Garrett’s entries, in the fair’s display case

  • Garrett’s caramel chocolate coffee cheesecake on a chocolate cookie crust, topped with chocolate crumbles, with a first-place and a Best of Division sticker on its entry tag
    Caramel chocolate coffee1st place and Best of Division · Original class
  • Garrett’s coconut-lime cheesecake in the fair’s display case, cut open, with his entry tag and a blue first-place ribbon
    Coconut-lime cheesecake1st place · Any Other class · 2019
  • Garrett’s Snickers cheesecake with candy-bar pieces and peanuts on top, cut open, with a first-place sticker on its entry tag
    Snickers1st place · Savory class
  • Garrett’s peanut butter cheesecake under a chocolate glaze with peanut butter cups on top, cut open, with a first-place sticker on its entry tag
    Peanut butter1st place · Any Other class
  • Garrett’s banana caramel nut cheesecake ringed with caramelized banana slices, cut open, with a first-place sticker on its entry tag
    Banana caramel nut1st place · Fruit class
  • Garrett’s watermelon and blueberry cheesecake topped with blueberries and watermelon, cut open, with a second-place sticker on its entry tag
    Watermelon & blueberry2nd place · Fruit class
  • Garrett’s strawberry cheesecake on a chocolate cookie crust, cut open, with its entry tag and a red second-place ribbon
    Strawberry cheesecake2nd place · Fruit class · 2019

Photos of Garrett’s fair entries (tap one to see it large). These were made for the fair, not his regular list; ask him about custom cheesecakes.

Flour, a whisk, an egg and a round baking pan on a floured wooden table

Every order starts with a phone call

Stock photo · Christy Araica / Unsplash

How to order

  1. Call Garrett at 831-338-4173

    Calling is the best way to reach him. If he can’t pick up, leave a message and he’ll call you back.

  2. Choose your cheesecake

    Pick a flavor and a crust, and add a topping if you like.

  3. Free local delivery

    There’s no charge for local delivery (San Lorenzo Valley).

  4. Pay in cash

    Garrett takes cash only.

Allergens

Every cheesecake contains eggs, dairy (cream cheese) and gluten.

Crusts and toppings vary, so tell Garrett about any other allergy (nuts, soy or anything else) when you call.

Old storefronts along the main street of Boulder Creek on a sunny day

Boulder Creek has been Garrett’s home for 44 years

Downtown Boulder Creek · anthony t / Unsplash
Garrett Wallace in a red cap at a wooden table, topping a cheesecake in its springform pan
Garrett Wallace

Garrett Wallace

Garrett has lived in Boulder Creek for 44 years and has been baking cheesecakes for more than 30.

He has entered the Santa Cruz County Fair for 11 years. His business card says it simply: “Cheesecakes Forever.”

To order, call him at 831-338-4173.

“Cheesecakes Forever”

Call Garrett: 831-338-4173